Guest wrote:
I think you comment is utterly ridiculous. I cant believe your words!! A parent needs to get physical with her child?? What da heck are you talking about? If he punches you punch back hard?? Ruthlessness?? Are we referring to a child here that you gave birth to and nurturing?? I think you have lost the plot!!
That is called child abuse and you need to be locked up if you are ever found of doing that. I dont think you should be giving advice either on child related matters. You really dont have a clue!
I think you're probably not a parent and have no idea what raising a toddler is actually like. You need to get physical with your child at some level, even if it's just restraining them as they try to kick, punch and beat you black and blue with their stuffed toys.
I disagree with the word "hard", but I think what the poster meant is "harder than you would like", because you love your child and hurting them is not what you want to do, but sometimes its necessary. I don't think this should be a first resort, I normally start by talking slowly and calmly, and trying to calm her down, then proceed to trying to physically restrain her from hitting me (normally by just keeping her at arm's length), then by faux-smacking (put your hand over their hand and smack the back of your own hand LOUDLY) which makes her look down and check whether she's hurting and sometimes shocks her out of the tantrum. If all these tactics fail or she's doing something that really requires immediate attention (like trying to bite my finger off - she's drawn blood on one occassions before when I didn't smack her in time) then I smack. I aim for sensitive areas where a light smack will produce a short-lived pain with no physical damage, so good targets are the back of the hand, the upper arm or upper leg.
This is NOT child abuse. It's a vital lesson in empathy, and failing to teach your children that causing pain to others will result in them experiencing pain themselves is raising them to be little sociopaths who have no understanding of, or connection with, the pain they cause in others. Too many people think they're psychologists and quote BF Skinner ("Bloody Fool" Skinner) and cite his experiments in conditioning to show that negative reinforcement (punishment) has no connection to improved behaviour, but they're completely ignoring the fact that these experiments were limited in scope and ignored long-term changes in cognitive schema, in other words childhood development.
Look around at schools these days and you'll see a ton of these little sociopaths running around the school yard. Their parents are devoted to the idea that hitting their child is "child abuse", and that they should never raise their hand to their child. As a result these little tyrants rule the house, they can inflict consequence-free pain on their parents and siblings, and they do the same to their playmates at school. Every parent should be required to smack their child, not forbidden by this new poorly thought-out, badly researched and invasive child protection act.
Oh, and you'll get to keep all your fingers if you're not afraid to give a short sharp smack when it's necessary.