|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
Hey Revive My husband was also adamant to be a part of our child's life from the word go and after making our sums and stuff we decided that he would take a two year sabbatical from his career and spend the first two years of our child's life with him. It was the best decision ever and he went back to work when our son was 18 months old because of an incredible job opportunity. Our paternity leave policies suck!
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 10/8/2008 Posts: 554 Points: 1,436 Location: Cape Town, South Africa
|
Hi GG -- Thanks for bringing in that perspective, when I made my comment I was thinking of a big company like the one I work for. I can imagine for a small business the impact would be felt harder.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
I got a full 3 days' family responsibility leave when my little boy was born 16 months ago. I had to take my annual leave on top of that.
We're now expecting our second - a little girl - in April and the thought of another 3 days' leave really grates me. And it's not just about bonding with the little one and sharing that precious time. It's also about being there for my wife. Recovering from a Caeserian is not a joke. You need someone around to help you. Add a little toddler to the mix, and there's no way I can leave home for 10 hours every day. And we don't have parents in town to help either.
For a bunch of politicians who do so much hand wringing and frowning about broken families and single parents, our government's policy on paternity leave is laughable. Have a look at what some of the leading countries are doing:
Australia: 18 weeks federal minimum wage (From January 1, 2011, pending parliamentary approval)
Germany: 12/14 months (67%, but not more than 1.800 Euro/month) (14 only for single fathers)
Italy: 13 weeks (3 months) (80%)
Sweden: 480 days (16 months) (80% up to a ceiling the first 390 days, 90 days at flat rate) - shared with mother (dedicated 60 days) + 10 working days in connection with the child's birth.
I know these are developed nations with strong economies, but no matter how you try and explain it away, 3 days is an insult. Even here in poor Africa, Kenyans get 2 weeks and Togo, Chad, Cameroon, Ivory Coast and a bunch of others all grant 10 days.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 10/8/2008 Posts: 554 Points: 1,436 Location: Cape Town, South Africa
|
Wow Jacques, these stats are astounding. Could you post the link you got them from if it was one place? Or the name of the source and I will Google it. If these are correct then we are really behind.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
Dad's don't deserve paternity leave !
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 12/10/2008 Posts: 73 Points: -277 Location: Cape Town, South Africa
|
Guest wrote:Dad's don't deserve paternity leave ! How can you say that? Don't fathers deserve to spend sometime with their newborn children? And what about giving the mother some help?
Life is good - even when it seems dark - the light is just being blocked out by the things that seem so bad - Shine.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
I don't have any leave policy to contribute to your cause Revive but I support if fully My partner and I had a baby in june this year and all he got was 3 days (new at the job and didn't have annual leave available yet). I'm greatful that he was there during the labour and the birth experince but that didn't leave him much time to bond with baby when she'd arrived. He did what he could when he was around (bathing/ changing nappies/ bottle feeding) but we did miss the support of a husband and father at home - the days and nights can be very long with a demanding newborn looking to you for their every need. Some mothers have been driven into a state of post-natal depression because of insufficient support. We're always quick to talk about the deterioration of society when we don't do enough to support nuclear families, but healthy families are the building blocks of a healthy society. Companies should look at this, if only, within the broader context of employee wellness. Good luck!
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 10/8/2008 Posts: 554 Points: 1,436 Location: Cape Town, South Africa
|
Well said, Guest.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
I think Paternity leave is a ripoff just not go be at work and a feeble excuse.In our years of working and having children there was no such things at all. We brought up very disciplined children who are successful citizens and taxpayers without Paternity leave etc which is stupid for a newborn babys father saying he wants to be at home for the baby. The mother is there!!
When you had a baby on the way arrangements were made that when the mother went into labour the father would go on official leave for a week or so or longer if they wished. Having a child is quite a natural procedure and it certainly does not require two parents to be at home for a whole month. What does the father want to do at home for a month! The newborn baby sleeps most of the day;
As for the feeble excuse of one father stating he grew up without a father and now wants paternity leave to be there for his newborn child. For goodness sake, this newborn does not need you around now. He does not even know who the father is and if his is there as yet. A newborn needs the mother, needs feeding and sleeps.
The child will need you when he starts taking notice of his surroundings and when he is a toddler and especially in Primary School and even MORE so when he is a Teenager! -certainly not newborn!!
Do these fathers want paternity leave every stage of the childs development, plus annual leave, plus sick leave !!
When do these people want to reliase in this Country, it is a priveledge to have a job ( even if half employed are SOOO LAZY and Incapable it is mindboggling) when do these people want to get serious ab9ut wORKING! BEING PRODUCTIVE, and considering their employees !!
It is not the clients of your Companys problem that your family is having a baby. They ALL have babies all the time, they want service and they actually pay your employer for your salary! You want to have babies, go ahead, but Fathers on Paternity leave that is ridiculous. Why dont these Dads just reisng and stay home and spend time with the children all the time during their development stages, then somebody who is unemployed can at least get that job without still wanting further perks etc.. and will be prepared to work.If you go into a Pick and Pay store, half the staff are just standing around!
No wonder food is so expensive if Pick and Pay can afford to have a mother and father off on full pay !! and the most of their staff just cruising around.
There are a great majority in our Population or should not be having further children as they cannot afford it and cannot give a child the proper means to grow up into a responsible Citizen. If all of them now also want leave, paternityleave, sick leave, God help this Country which already has gone from prosperity to the laziest workforce and unproductivity scenario in the world in only 15 years. Just look at the Service Delivery and Government and Municipal Departments, maybe most of them are on permanent Maternity and Paternity leave and then come back to sign the forms for their Annual Leave and then they will still expect Bonus as well. Go to the fare easwt and learn to work. I know we lived there for 8 years.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
I do not think Paternity leave if necessary for fathers and a newborn certainly does not need bonding with a father immediately after birth. They need feeding and to be handled as little as possible and sleep most of the time. That is what the mother is there for. People should not even be present when a newborn baby is fed as noise/movement too mcuh handling just causes all sorts of feeding problems including colic. Refer to Lady Buxton Home Cape Town and the Red Cross Childrens hospital. The newborn is not a toy.
Also, if a baby is born, and the mother cannot cope,arrange assistance with family member or a Nanny or someone to do the housework for a period of a month and let the father go to his job after a week and earn the money to support the baby.
Everybody should arrange a support system. The father is not going to be able to do anything about the wifes emotional issues after birth, that is a medical problem to be solved by medical people.
After a week of the baby being home, there should be a daily routine in place . Having a newborn in the house does have to cause an upheavel. There is feeding time ,bathing time and the rest is sleeping time. Disposable nappies today, good baby formula,bottled baby foods-Purity etc
are making it all extremely easy for mothers than in Our days believe me. Organise your daily routines and stick to them.
People who cannot afford this should not perhaps have had the baby in the first place if they expect the husbands employer to accommodate them because they are having a baby, which is a natural occurrence believe me.! There are thousands born daily, every minute - so just think of all the thousands of women and NOW men absent from work every day!! Get real man !tHE CHILD IS GOING TO NEED MUCH MUCH MORE ATTENTION WHEN THE BABY STARTS CRAWLING AND WALKING ETC..
This is utter nonsense. In our Company, 3days and rest annual leave. Death and illness, another story! But pregnancy and birth is not an illness and a very natural occurrence. The women of today are not properly prepared in most cases for a natural procedure like child birth and many cannot even manage a household on their own. never mind babies. SO they will have problems , but it is their problems not the Companies their husbands work for.
We have a business to run, conditions are diffuclt now and everybody who still wants a job or should I say needs a job in our Company, have a duty to perform and when they are not there to do so, we cannot offer the same service as we have no surplus staff floating around to stand in for colleagues who are on a long unneccessary paternity leave ! Who is having the Baby, the mother or the father !!
|
|
 Rank: Member Groups: Member
Joined: 11/17/2009 Posts: 23 Points: 69 Location: JHB, South Africa
|
Thank you for all the feedback everyone!! If possible, would you be able to email me a copy of those leave policies (email details ion my first post) I know its not a lot of days, so may seem pointless...but we only get 2 days...so any bit helps..even if it seems like its nothing! I would really appreciate it!
I know some European companies, employees can take up to a year (obviously not all paid)...but still...the fact they they give the time is amazing!
I also understand about running a business...but in my life...family comes first and I think more people are picking up on this. At my work, if the person is that "irreplaceable", we get in temps to help out, otherwise some people just work a bit from home if possible. I will prob suggest this and try bargain with them and say I will be available at home to help work from home if needed, and hopefully get an extended period of leave. But who knows?
|
|
 Rank: Member Groups: Member
Joined: 11/17/2009 Posts: 23 Points: 69 Location: JHB, South Africa
|
Guest wrote:Dad's don't deserve paternity leave ! I feel sorry for you...really I do, I hope you open you eyes one day. Guest wrote:I think Paternity leave is a ripoff just not go be at work and a feeble excuse.In our years of working and having children there was no such things at all. We brought up very disciplined children who are successful citizens and taxpayers without Paternity leave etc which is stupid for a newborn babys father saying he wants to be at home for the baby. The mother is there!!
When you had a baby on the way arrangements were made that when the mother went into labour the father would go on official leave for a week or so or longer if they wished. Having a child is quite a natural procedure and it certainly does not require two parents to be at home for a whole month. What does the father want to do at home for a month! The newborn baby sleeps most of the day;
As for the feeble excuse of one father stating he grew up without a father and now wants paternity leave to be there for his newborn child. For goodness sake, this newborn does not need you around now. He does not even know who the father is and if his is there as yet. A newborn needs the mother, needs feeding and sleeps.
The child will need you when he starts taking notice of his surroundings and when he is a toddler and especially in Primary School and even MORE so when he is a Teenager! -certainly not newborn!!
Do these fathers want paternity leave every stage of the childs development, plus annual leave, plus sick leave !!
When do these people want to reliase in this Country, it is a priveledge to have a job ( even if half employed are SOOO LAZY and Incapable it is mindboggling) when do these people want to get serious ab9ut wORKING! BEING PRODUCTIVE, and considering their employees !!
It is not the clients of your Companys problem that your family is having a baby. They ALL have babies all the time, they want service and they actually pay your employer for your salary! You want to have babies, go ahead, but Fathers on Paternity leave that is ridiculous. Why dont these Dads just reisng and stay home and spend time with the children all the time during their development stages, then somebody who is unemployed can at least get that job without still wanting further perks etc.. and will be prepared to work.If you go into a Pick and Pay store, half the staff are just standing around!
No wonder food is so expensive if Pick and Pay can afford to have a mother and father off on full pay !! and the most of their staff just cruising around.
There are a great majority in our Population or should not be having further children as they cannot afford it and cannot give a child the proper means to grow up into a responsible Citizen. If all of them now also want leave, paternityleave, sick leave, God help this Country which already has gone from prosperity to the laziest workforce and unproductivity scenario in the world in only 15 years. Just look at the Service Delivery and Government and Municipal Departments, maybe most of them are on permanent Maternity and Paternity leave and then come back to sign the forms for their Annual Leave and then they will still expect Bonus as well. Go to the fare easwt and learn to work. I know we lived there for 8 years. Thats part of the problem in this country. Men just dont take responsibility. They use paternity leave and an excuse for extended holiday. Then for us that do want to contribute...we struggle cos of people like this with the wrong mindset. So sad. Guest wrote:I do not think Paternity leave if necessary for fathers and a newborn certainly does not need bonding with a father immediately after birth. They need feeding and to be handled as little as possible and sleep most of the time. That is what the mother is there for. People should not even be present when a newborn baby is fed as noise/movement too mcuh handling just causes all sorts of feeding problems including colic. Refer to Lady Buxton Home Cape Town and the Red Cross Childrens hospital. The newborn is not a toy.
Also, if a baby is born, and the mother cannot cope,arrange assistance with family member or a Nanny or someone to do the housework for a period of a month and let the father go to his job after a week and earn the money to support the baby.
Everybody should arrange a support system. The father is not going to be able to do anything about the wifes emotional issues after birth, that is a medical problem to be solved by medical people.
After a week of the baby being home, there should be a daily routine in place . Having a newborn in the house does have to cause an upheavel. There is feeding time ,bathing time and the rest is sleeping time. Disposable nappies today, good baby formula,bottled baby foods-Purity etc
are making it all extremely easy for mothers than in Our days believe me. Organise your daily routines and stick to them.
People who cannot afford this should not perhaps have had the baby in the first place if they expect the husbands employer to accommodate them because they are having a baby, which is a natural occurrence believe me.! There are thousands born daily, every minute - so just think of all the thousands of women and NOW men absent from work every day!! Get real man !tHE CHILD IS GOING TO NEED MUCH MUCH MORE ATTENTION WHEN THE BABY STARTS CRAWLING AND WALKING ETC..
This is utter nonsense. In our Company, 3days and rest annual leave. Death and illness, another story! But pregnancy and birth is not an illness and a very natural occurrence. The women of today are not properly prepared in most cases for a natural procedure like child birth and many cannot even manage a household on their own. never mind babies. SO they will have problems , but it is their problems not the Companies their husbands work for.
We have a business to run, conditions are diffuclt now and everybody who still wants a job or should I say needs a job in our Company, have a duty to perform and when they are not there to do so, we cannot offer the same service as we have no surplus staff floating around to stand in for colleagues who are on a long unneccessary paternity leave ! Who is having the Baby, the mother or the father !!
So hows it going living in the stone age still? Seems you still enjoying it. Im not even bothering with an appropriate response to this type of thinking.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
Stop with partenity leave nonsense. Are you women? Focus on mens job, don't get softy on us now. Where have the real men gone?
|
|
 Rank: Member Groups: Member
Joined: 11/17/2009 Posts: 23 Points: 69 Location: JHB, South Africa
|
PLEASE NOTE:
This thread is not a debate about paternity leave and what you think about it. If you want to debate paternity leave, start your own thread on that topic and leave your opinions there! I will not be replying to any more posts about what you think of paternity leave.
If you can help with my cause, then please reply to this thread or send me a mail to help out. If not, then dont waste your time or mine by posting your opinions on it. I wont be responding to them!To those that have helped so far, thank you
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
Sorry Revive... I only read the last post about paternity leave once I posted this
I guess the best approach currently would be to take the first 2 out of 5 days off in full and then split the last 3 into half days. That will only work if your employer is willing though.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 10/8/2008 Posts: 554 Points: 1,436 Location: Cape Town, South Africa
|
Guest wrote:I guess the best approach currently would be to take the first 2 out of 5 days off in full and then split the last 3 into half days. That will only work if your employer is willing though. That sounds like a good idea. To take half days can be very useful for the family. Hold thumbs employers get it.
|
|
 Rank: Member Groups: Member
Joined: 11/17/2009 Posts: 23 Points: 69 Location: JHB, South Africa
|
Yeah, that sounds like a good idea. Thanks for the tip. The good thing is they are quite open to suggestion. So thats good. My wife has opted for a caesar. So she will be in hospital for 4 days. I idea is the first day I will take leave for the birth, then cos she is in hospital, will take remainder when she is out but the more the better as it will mean I can bond with the family and help out around the house. A caesar is hectic...so she will need a lot of help.
|
|
 Rank: Newbie Groups: Member
Joined: 11/18/2009 Posts: 3 Points: 9 Location: Cape Town, South Africa
|
What most companies don't seem to grasp, is that it's as essential for the Dad to have that time to bond and get to know their little person (and vice versa) as it is for the Mom to have his support during a very exhausting time, both emotionally and physically. Especially as we no longer have the benefit of extended families and that support system... Why should a new family be deprived of this most essential time in their life?
|
|
 Rank: Member Groups: Member
Joined: 11/17/2009 Posts: 23 Points: 69 Location: JHB, South Africa
|
fresh wrote:What most companies don't seem to grasp, is that it's as essential for the Dad to have that time to bond and get to know their little person (and vice versa) as it is for the Mom to have his support during a very exhausting time, both emotionally and physically. Especially as we no longer have the benefit of extended families and that support system... Why should a new family be deprived of this most essential time in their life? Could not have put it better myself.
|
|
Rank: Guest Groups: Guest
Joined: 8/1/2008 Posts: -11,342 Points: -35,405
|
In the UK father's get two weeks paternity leave but are paid only nominally for it. There is discussion about parents having the option to share the 9 months off the government sets at the minimum, depending on their personal circumstances...for instance if mom has higher earning potential she could go back to work after 6 months and dad can go on paternity leave for 3 so that baby can have more time at home before going to a childminder...
|
|
|
|
|
Guest |